Seeking: Mascara BFF

I'm on the hunt for the perfect mascara.

Since I'm pretty low maintenance on the whole make up regimen (meaning I throw on some mascara and maybe even some eye liner if I'm going somewhere special and BAM!) I really don't know where to start. I wouldn't mind spending a good chunk of money on mascara if it's worth it, since that's really the most of what I currently wear. I have been told to watch some YouTube tutorials to learn how to use my eyeshadows that I have. I'm looking in to that, and trust me, I'll let you know see the results because you'll probably laugh really hard. 

Back to the search for my new mascara BFF...

Qualifications: Be a mascara.

Pretty easy right?

So here's what I've tried so far:

Clinique Lash Doubling Mascara + Lash Building Primer

Benefit They're Real! Mascara (mini size, because what if I hated it?!)

Mary Kay Ultimate Mascara (sample size, because it was free - win!)

I'm honestly not in love with any of them so far. I like them, but I really want to find [the ONE]. I thought I was going to be head over heels for the Benefit Mascara because so many people had recommended it to me, but the one thing I don't like about it is that it it so hard to wash off! If I want to jump in the shower and just wash my face with water I come out looking like a raccoon and then spend quite sometime out of the shower washing my face again just to put mascara back on. 

I need your help! If you have any suggestions at all please let me know! I'm willing to try almost anything and I'll let you know what I think. If you suggest the one I fall in love with I might even send you a little something. I am, after all, trying to send more love notes in the mail.

xo - R